Tokenization vs. Encryption: Understanding Their Role in Payment Data Security

February 25, 2025

•

min read

Share this post

If you’re a business that accepts card payments, it means you handle sensitive cardholder data that hackers want to steal (and use) for fraud. This makes you a constant target, and failing to secure your systems can lead to financial loss, reputational damage, and legal trouble.

Cyberattacks are a serious risk. Don’t believe us, believe the stats:

According to one report, 40% of small businesses across the world – including the US – report losing critical data due to an attack. Another study indicates that, on average, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) lose $25,000 per cyberattack.

To protect your business, you need strong security measures. Tokenization and encryption help keep your payment data safe, both when stored and in transit.

Before you decide how to mitigate the risks and liability associated with handling sensitive payment data, it’s important to understand how these techniques differ. This article will explain all you need to know about tokenization vs. encryption and guide you on when to use each.

Key Takeaways

Tokenization Vs. Encryption: What Are the Main Differences?

Both tokenization and encryption are designed to protect sensitive payment data; however, both operate differently. Payment leaders need to know how the two differ to choose the right security solution for their middle-market enterprises.

Let’s examine a few common differences between the two payment security mechanisms.

Data Protection Approach

Encryption converts cardholder information into indecipherable code through a sophisticated algorithm. Only an individual with the proper decryption key can revert it to its initial (original) state. On the contrary, tokenization replaces sensitive cardholder data with a token that holds no actual value. The original data is safely kept in a token vault (which encrypts it), and only authorized systems can trade the token for the actual data when required.

Data Storage & Security

Encrypted data remains sensitive. Although it’s scrambled, it still holds value for attackers if they manage to steal the decryption key. To ensure the safety of cardholder data, other security measures such as 2FA, monitoring protocols, and strict access control should be implemented.

Tokens, on the other hand, are useless to hackers. As tokens don’t include any ‘real’ payment information, they can’t be decrypted or misused fraudulently without access to the token vault. It’s highly unlikely that fraudsters could gain access to both, making tokenization one of the safest ways to store and transmit cardholder data.

PCI DSS Compliance & Risk Reduction

Encryption keeps you in the scope of the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS). For instance, if a business stores encrypted payment data, it has to meet PCI DSS encryption requirements and protect decryption keys.

Tokenization reduces PCI DSS scope. Since tokenized data isn’t deemed sensitive, companies that use tokenization (and depend on a Payment Service Provider) can offload compliance burdens and reduce security risks.

Performance & Efficiency

Encryption may slow down transactions. Because encryption requires computational power to encode and decode data, it might impact performance, especially for high-volume transactions.

In contrast, tokenization is quicker and more scalable. As tokens eliminate the need for intricate decryption, they enable fast and effective payment processing, which makes them excellent for companies with high transaction volumes.

Tokenization vs. Encryption Alone: Which Is Right For You?

The right approach depends on whether your business stores payment data or simply needs to process transactions securely. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you make a choice.

Use cases for encryption:

You store payment data in-house. If your business is responsible for securing cardholder data at rest or during transit, encryption is necessary for payment data security.
Your company handles in-house payment processing or can’t rely on a PSP.
You need to protect sensitive transaction details across multiple systems. Encryption guarantees comprehensive security when data travels between databases, applications, and payment gateways.
You are subject to PCI DSS, GDPR, or other regulations that mandate encryption.

Use cases for tokenization:

You’d like to add an additional layer of security to protect cardholder data.
You aim to lessen PCI DSS scope. Tokenized payments outsource storage to a Payment Service Provider (PSP), which reduces security threats and compliance challenges.
You handle recurring payments. If you provide subscriptions or card-on-file payments, tokenization enables you to keep a reference to the card without managing the actual cardholder information.
You employ digital wallets, mobile payments, or contactless transactions. Numerous contemporary payment systems depend on tokenization to facilitate secure, smooth transactions.
You prefer a low-maintenance solution that doesn't require in-house cryptographic expertise.

How Do Tokenization and Encryption Work Together to Enhance Payment Security?

Although tokenization and encryption have distinct functions, many businesses use them simultaneously in a multi-layered security strategy:

Payment data is protected by encryption as it moves through networks.
Tokenization replaces cardholder data before it is saved, removing the necessity to encrypt the stored data.

Example Workflow:

A customer inputs card details on a site.
Transport Layer Security (TLS) secures the information while sending it to the payment processor.
The processor substitutes the card data with a token and returns it to the business.
The company retains only the token, minimizing compliance risks.

How Do GDPR, CCPA, and Other Data Privacy Regulations Affect the Use of Tokenization and Encryption?

Data privacy laws, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), require businesses to protect consumer data and ensure compliance.

Here are some key points about how various data privacy regulations may affect these two payment security mechanisms:

Data Minimization: Regulations such as GDPR emphasize the principle of "data minimization," which states that only necessary personal data should be collected and stored. By substituting sensitive data with meaningless tokens and limiting the amount of directly identifiable information that could be exposed in a breach, tokenization aligns with this GDPR objective.
Enhanced Security: Both tokenization and encryption add layers of security by making it difficult to decipher sensitive data even if a breach occurs.
Compliance Requirement: Most data privacy regulations explicitly state the need to implement appropriate technical and organizational measures to protect personal data. Tokenization and encryption are often considered essential components of such measures.
Data Subject Rights: Regulations grant individuals the right to access, rectify, and erase their personal data. By utilizing tokenization, organizations can provide access to a de-identified version of data while maintaining the original sensitive information securely stored separately.

Some specific examples of how these regulations impact the use of tokenization and encryption include:

Payment Card Data: The PCI DSS mandates strict security measures for handling credit card details. Tokenization is becoming increasingly more common because it reduces the scope of PCI DSS compliance.
Healthcare Data: HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) requires robust protection of sensitive medical information, where encryption and tokenization can be used to safeguard patient data.
Personal Identifiers: GDPR and CCPA explicitly protect personal identifiers like names, addresses, and email IDs, making it crucial to implement tokenization or encryption when storing and processing such data.

What Are the PCI DSS Requirements for Encryption?

For businesses (of all sizes) that encrypt payment data, it’s essential to use PCI DSS requirements, such as:

Strong Encryption Algorithms: Use industry-standard algorithms like AES (128-bit or higher), RSA (2048-bit or higher), and ECC (224-bit or higher).
Protect Stored Data: Encrypt all stored cardholder data.
Secure Key Management: Implement robust key management practices to protect encryption keys.
Data Truncation: Consider using truncation techniques where appropriate to minimize the amount of sensitive cardholder data stored.
Regular Testing: Perform regular security assessments and penetration testing to verify the effectiveness of encryption implementation.

What Security Risks Exist If Tokenization or Encryption Is Not Implemented Correctly?

There’s no doubt that tokenization and encryption are some of the best security tools available. However, they can leave payment data vulnerable to breaches if not implemented correctly.

Here are some security risks every business should know:

Weak Encryption Is Vulnerable to Attack

Encryption depends on robust algorithms to protect data. Hackers can decrypt the encryption and access confidential data if a company employs obsolete or inadequate encryption techniques (such as DES or prior iterations of AES). The recommended approach is to use AES-256 encryption and frequently update security protocols.

Ineffective Key Management Results in Data Exposure

Encryption keys function like passwords that secure and access encrypted information. Attackers can obtain and access payment data if a business fails to store and manage encryption keys securely.

A Hardware Security Module (HSM) or a Key Management System (KMS) is critical to thwart unauthorized access.

Improper Tokenization Can Lead to Reversible Tokens

Tokenization replaces payment data with a unique token, but if tokens are predictable or poorly generated, they can be reverse-engineered.

This means hackers could figure out the original data by analyzing the token patterns. A strong, random tokenization system is necessary to ensure security.

Lack of Encryption for Data in Transit Can Lead to Interception

Even if payment data is encrypted or tokenized while at rest, it still needs to be secured during transmission between networks.

If companies fail to implement TLS 1.2+ encryption for data in transit, cybercriminals can intercept payment details during online transactions.

Tokenization and Encryption Don’t Prevent All Attacks

Although these technologies can help protect stored and transmitted data, they don’t prevent phishing attacks, malware, or insider threats.

Companies should also adopt robust authentication methods, payment fraud prevention systems, proper protocols to monitor and test systems, and employee training programs to enhance security.

How to Implement Encryption and Tokenization In Your Company: Top Industry-Leading Practices

Encryption and tokenization are crucial elements of a strong data security framework. Here are a few industry-leading best practices you can employ to establish efficient, compliant security standards:

Compliance: Make yourself acquainted with the relevant data protection regulations in your sector (e.g., PCI DSS, HIPAA, GDPR). This will help verify that your encryption and tokenization methods meet legal standards.
Security audits and testing: Consistently assess your encryption and tokenization procedures to detect possible flaws and risks.
Staff training: Instruct your staff about the significance of data protection and the correct management of confidential information.
Incident response strategy: Develop a swift, efficient approach to potential security violations.

Encryption Best Practices

Here are the recommended practices for using encryption:

Use widely accepted algorithms such as AES with suitable key lengths (for instance, AES-256). Also, avoid obsolete or ineffective algorithms.
No matter what, protect the encryption keys. Keep them safe, strictly manage access, and frequently change them. Use an HSM for added security if required.
Secure sensitive information by encrypting it while stored on your servers, in the cloud, and during transmission over networks.
Use secure protocols like TLS to encrypt communication pathways, ensuring that the data exchanged between systems remains confidential.

Tokenization Best Practices

Here are the best practices for tokenization:

Prioritize tokenization only for extremely sensitive information, including credit card details, Social Security numbers, and all personally identifiable information (PII).
Keep the original data and its connection to the tokens in an encrypted token vault, apart from your production environment. Establish robust access controls and surveillance for the vault.
Consider format-preserving tokenization (FPT) to maintain data format and simplify integration with existing systems.
Develop a concise policy for creating, using, and retiring tokens to guarantee they are used correctly and don’t become outdated.

How AI or Blockchain Technology Impacts the Future of Tokenization and Encryption

The future of secure payment processing is evolving rapidly, and two technologies - AI and blockchain - are poised to reshape tokenization and encryption. But how exactly will they impact security, compliance, and fraud prevention?

AI: Smarter Threat Detection & Adaptive Security

Artificial intelligence is already enhancing fraud detection, but its role in encryption is growing. AI-driven algorithms can identify vulnerabilities in real-time, predict potential attack vectors, and even automate encryption key management.

This means businesses can maintain strong security postures without adding operational complexity. AI can also optimize tokenization by dynamically adjusting security measures based on transaction risk, helping middle-market enterprises balance protection with efficiency.

Blockchain: Immutable Security & Decentralized Control

Blockchain’s potential lies in its ability to provide an immutable, transparent record of encrypted transactions. By leveraging decentralized encryption methods, blockchain can enhance tokenization security while reducing reliance on single points of failure. This could mean tamper-proof audit trails and more resilient data protection strategies that align with evolving PCI DSS standards for payments and compliance.

What This Means for Businesses

While AI streamlines security operations, blockchain strengthens data integrity. Together, they could redefine tokenization and encryption, making compliance more manageable and fraud prevention more effective. For SMEs, the key will be selecting the right solutions that enhance security without disrupting workflows because, in payments, security should be seamless and not burdensome.

Final Thoughts

As payment security threats evolve, your data protection strategies must keep up. While encryption and tokenization help protect sensitive information, tokenization often provides more secure protection due to its unique advantages.

That said, the right choice often depends on a business’s needs. If you process payments through a third party, tokenized payments can help simplify compliance and security. However, if you store payment data internally, encryption is a must.

Looking for a reliable service to assess your company’s payment security? Schedule a free Payment Security Assessment with Clear Function or contact us to learn more. Our experts will help you determine the best security strategy for your business.

Subscribe to newsletter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.